Savory Turkey Rachel Melt

Craving a sandwich that’s both comforting and bursting with flavor? Look no further than the glorious Rachel Sandwich! Often hailed as the turkey-loving cousin to the classic Reuben, this delightful creation takes all the best elements of its predecessor and gives them a refreshing twist. Instead of corned beef and sauerkraut, the Rachel features succulent sliced turkey breast, crisp, creamy coleslaw, layers of melty Swiss cheese, and a generous slathering of zesty Thousand Island dressing, all nestled between slices of perfectly toasted rye bread. It’s an easy, yet incredibly satisfying meal that elevates an ordinary lunch or dinner into something truly special and crave-worthy.

The allure of a well-made sandwich is undeniable, and while my pastrami sandwich often steals the spotlight, the Rachel Sandwich, sometimes affectionately called a Turkey Reuben, is quickly gaining a loyal following. It offers a lighter yet equally satisfying alternative, making it ideal for those who prefer poultry or are looking for a delicious way to utilize leftover turkey from holiday feasts like Thanksgiving. Forget your routine, cold turkey sandwiches; the Rachel Sandwich is a warm, gooey, and flavorful revelation that promises to banish boredom from your mealtime.

While any good quality sliced turkey works wonders in this recipe, consider elevating your Rachel experience with turkey pastrami. The extra peppery notes and savory depth of turkey pastrami add an incredible layer of flavor that truly sets this sandwich apart. Whether you’re a seasoned sandwich enthusiast or simply seeking a new favorite, learning to master the Rachel Sandwich at home is a culinary journey you won’t regret embarking on.

The Rachel Sandwich: A Delightful Twist on a Classic

The Rachel Sandwich holds a special place in the pantheon of beloved deli sandwiches. While its more famous cousin, the Reuben, features corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye, the Rachel offers a delicious variation that often appeals to a broader palate. The key difference lies in two primary ingredients: turkey replaces corned beef, and coleslaw steps in for sauerkraut. This substitution results in a sandwich that is just as rich and satisfying, but with a distinct flavor profile that is both fresh and tangy.

The choice of turkey makes the Rachel a fantastic option for those seeking a lean protein without sacrificing flavor. When combined with the creamy, crunchy texture of coleslaw, the sharpness of Swiss cheese, and the sweet tang of Thousand Island dressing, it creates a symphony of tastes that is utterly irresistible. Toasting the sandwich on rye bread until golden and crisp ensures every bite delivers that perfect combination of warm, melted goodness and satisfying crunch. It’s more than just a sandwich; it’s an experience that brings comfort and joy, whether it’s a quick weekday lunch or a casual weekend dinner.

Ingredients for the Perfect Rachel Sandwich

Crafting an exceptional Rachel Sandwich begins with selecting high-quality ingredients. Here’s a detailed look at what you’ll need, along with tips and substitution options to customize your culinary masterpiece. For precise measurements, please refer to the comprehensive recipe card located at the bottom of this article.

• Turkey: The star of your Rachel! You have several excellent choices here.
  • Leftover Roasted Turkey: This is a fantastic way to repurpose holiday turkey, adding incredible depth and flavor. Make sure it’s thinly sliced for easy layering.
  • Deli-Sliced Turkey: Opt for high-quality, thinly sliced turkey breast from your local deli. Roasted turkey or smoked turkey varieties work wonderfully.
  • Turkey Pastrami: For an extra kick of savory, peppery flavor, turkey pastrami is an outstanding choice that elevates the sandwich significantly. If using very thin deli slices, you might not need to heat it beforehand.
• Rye Bread: The foundation of any great Reuben-style sandwich.
  • Marble Rye: Offers a beautiful aesthetic and a balanced rye flavor.
  • Dark Rye: Provides a more pronounced, robust rye taste.
  • Jewish Rye Bread: Known for its distinctive caraway seeds and hearty texture.
  • Pro Tip: Choose a bread that is sturdy enough to hold all the fillings without becoming soggy, yet soft enough to toast beautifully.
• Butter: Essential for achieving that golden-brown, crispy exterior on your rye bread. Unsalted butter allows you to control the seasoning, but salted butter can also add a nice flavor.
• Thousand Island Dressing: The iconic creamy, tangy sauce that ties all the flavors together.
  • Thousand Island vs. Russian Dressing: While often used interchangeably, there are subtle differences. Both are mayonnaise and ketchup-based. Thousand Island typically includes finely chopped pickles (or relish), onions, bell peppers, and sometimes a hard-boiled egg, giving it a chunkier texture and sweeter profile. Russian dressing tends to be spicier, often incorporating horseradish, chili sauce, and Worcestershire sauce. Either dressing works wonderfully, so choose based on your preference for sweet vs. spicy tang.
  • Homemade vs. Store-Bought: A good quality store-bought dressing is perfectly fine for convenience, but a homemade version can truly elevate the sandwich.
• Swiss Cheese: Its nutty flavor and excellent melting properties are crucial.
  • Thin Slices: Ensure you have thin slices of Swiss cheese for quick and even melting over the warm turkey. Baby Swiss or Emmentaler are popular choices.
  • Substitution: If Swiss isn’t your favorite, Muenster or Provolone are also good melting cheeses that can offer a slightly different flavor.
• Coleslaw: The defining characteristic of a Rachel Sandwich, providing a refreshing crunch and tangy creaminess.
  • Traditional Choice: Coleslaw differentiates the Rachel from the Reuben’s sauerkraut. Its cool, crisp texture and creamy dressing offer a delightful contrast to the warm turkey and melted cheese.
  • Coleslaw Mix + Dressing: For convenience, use a pre-packaged coleslaw mix (shredded cabbage and carrots) and combine it with a tablespoon of your favorite coleslaw dressing per cup of mix. This lightly dresses the slaw, ensuring it’s flavorful but doesn’t make the sandwich soggy.
  • Homemade Coleslaw: For the freshest taste, prepare your own coleslaw.
  • Sauerkraut Option: If you absolutely prefer sauerkraut, you can certainly substitute it. Just be sure to press out as much excess liquid as possible before adding it to the sandwich to prevent sogginess. This is a crucial step for any Reuben or Rachel with sauerkraut.

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make the Best Rachel Sandwich

Crafting the perfect Rachel Sandwich is a simple and rewarding process. Follow these detailed steps to ensure a golden, gooey, and utterly delicious result. I’ve included some step-by-step photos below for visual guidance. For the complete, detailed recipe instructions, please scroll down to the recipe card.

1. Prepare the Turkey: Begin by heating a large skillet or griddle pan over medium-high heat on your stovetop. This will be the same pan you use to grill your sandwiches, so choose one that’s spacious enough. Add your sliced turkey to the hot pan and cook for 30-60 seconds per side, or just until it’s warmed through. The goal is to heat it, not to crisp it. Once heated, remove the turkey from the skillet and set it aside.
   • Pro Tip: If you’re using very thinly sliced deli turkey, this step can often be skipped, as the heat from grilling the sandwich will warm it sufficiently.
2. Prepare the Coleslaw: In a medium bowl, combine 1 cup of coleslaw mix with 1 tablespoon of coleslaw dressing. Toss gently until the cabbage and carrots are lightly coated. This ensures the coleslaw is flavorful but won’t make your sandwich soggy.
3. Butter the Bread: Take each slice of rye bread and spread an even layer of butter on one side. This buttered side will be the exterior of your sandwich, ensuring a beautiful golden crisp.
4. Apply the Dressing: Flip each slice of bread over. On the unbuttered side (the interior side), spread a generous amount of Thousand Island dressing. This will be the base layer for your fillings.
5. Layer the Fillings: Place a slice of Swiss cheese directly on top of the Thousand Island dressing on each piece of bread. Next, on half of the bread slices (the ones you intend to be the bottom halves), pile on a generous amount of your warmed turkey and then the prepared coleslaw.
6. Assemble the Sandwich: Gently place the other half of the bread slices (dressing and cheese side down) on top of the turkey and coleslaw, completing your sandwich assembly.
7. Grill the Sandwiches: Return to the skillet you used for the turkey. Quickly wipe away any turkey bits or excess moisture. Heat the skillet over medium heat. Place the assembled sandwiches onto the warm skillet or griddle. Grill for 3-4 minutes per side, or until the rye bread is perfectly golden brown and crispy, and the Swiss cheese has melted into a wonderfully gooey layer. Use a spatula to gently press down on the sandwiches while grilling to ensure even toasting and melting.
8. Serve Immediately: Once grilled to perfection, remove the Rachel Sandwiches from the skillet. Slice them in half diagonally for an authentic deli presentation and serve immediately. Enjoy every warm, savory, and crunchy bite!

Rachel Sandwich Variations and Pro Tips

The beauty of the Rachel Sandwich lies in its versatility. Here are some ideas to customize your sandwich and a few pro tips to make it truly exceptional:

Customization Ideas:

• Cheese Alternatives: While Swiss is traditional, consider Provolone, Muenster, or even a sharp white cheddar for a different flavor profile.
• Dressing Switch-Up: If you don’t have Thousand Island, a zesty homemade or store-bought Russian dressing is a fantastic alternative. You can also experiment with a creamy dill sauce or a honey mustard dressing for a unique twist.
• Bread Choices: While rye is classic, sourdough bread or even a hearty whole wheat can work well if you’re looking for a change. Ensure it’s a bread that can stand up to grilling.
• Add-Ins: Crispy bacon, thinly sliced red onion, or even a few dill pickle slices can add extra crunch and flavor.
• Spicy Kick: For those who love heat, a pinch of cayenne pepper in your Thousand Island dressing or a thin slice of jalapeño can add a welcome zing.

Pro Tips for Success:

• Don’t Overload: While tempting to pile high, don’t overstuff your sandwich. This makes it difficult to grill evenly and can cause fillings to spill out.
• Even Heat is Key: Ensure your skillet is at a consistent medium heat. Too hot, and the bread will burn before the cheese melts; too low, and it will become greasy.
• Press Gently: A light press with your spatula while grilling helps to compress the sandwich, ensuring all layers adhere and the cheese melts perfectly.
• Dry Coleslaw (or Sauerkraut): If you use sauerkraut, squeeze out as much liquid as possible. For coleslaw, ensure it’s dressed lightly and not soaking wet. Excess moisture leads to a soggy sandwich.
• Use Good Quality Ingredients: The simplicity of the Rachel Sandwich means each ingredient shines. Invest in good quality turkey, bread, and cheese for the best results.

What to Serve With Your Turkey Reuben

The Rachel Sandwich is wonderfully satisfying on its own, but pairing it with a delicious side dish can truly complete the meal. Here are some fantastic options to elevate your sandwich experience beyond a simple bag of potato chips:

• Potatoes:
  • Animal Style Fries: A fun, loaded fry option for a hearty meal.
  • Truffle Fries: For an elegant touch, the earthy aroma of truffle fries complements the savory turkey.
  • Smashed Potatoes: Crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, these are always a crowd-pleaser.
• Air Fryer Favorites: If you’re looking for a quick and easy side with minimal oil, your air fryer is your best friend.
  • Air Fryer Onion Rings: Perfectly crisp and a classic pairing with any deli-style sandwich.
  • Air Fryer French Fries: A healthier take on the beloved classic.
  • Air Fryer Tater Tots: Nostalgic and delightfully crunchy.
• Salads: A fresh salad can cut through the richness of the sandwich, offering a lighter balance.
  • Potato Salad: A creamy, robust potato salad is a traditional deli pairing.
  • Pickle Pasta Salad: The tang of pickles in a pasta salad provides a refreshing counterpoint.
  • Cucumber Salad: A light and refreshing option that balances the richness of the Rachel.

To create a truly comforting and satisfying soup and sandwich combo, consider pairing your Rachel with a warm bowl of roasted tomato soup or a rich and creamy broccoli cheddar soup. The warmth of the soup and the melty goodness of the sandwich create an unbeatable duo.

Storage and Reheating Tips

While a Rachel Sandwich is best enjoyed fresh off the griddle, you can prepare components ahead of time or store leftovers if necessary.

Ahead-of-Time Preparation:

• Coleslaw: Prepare your coleslaw dressing and mix it with the cabbage and carrots up to a day in advance. Store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator.
• Turkey: Have your turkey sliced and ready to go. If using roasted turkey, you can slice and store it for a few days in the fridge.
• Dressing: If making your own Thousand Island or Russian dressing, it can be prepared several days in advance and stored in the refrigerator.

Storing Leftovers:

• It’s generally not recommended to store assembled and grilled Rachel sandwiches, as the bread can become soggy and the coleslaw can lose its crispness.
• If you must store a grilled sandwich, wrap it tightly in foil and refrigerate for no more than 1 day.

Reheating Leftovers:

• The best way to reheat a Rachel sandwich is in a non-stick skillet or on a griddle over medium heat. This helps crisp up the bread again. Cook for a few minutes per side until warmed through and the cheese is melted.
• You can also use an air fryer at 350°F (175°C) for 3-5 minutes, or until heated and crisp.
• Avoid reheating in the microwave, as it will make the bread soggy and the coleslaw unappetizing.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Rachel Sandwich

What is the difference between a Reuben and a Rachel sandwich?

The primary differences lie in the main meat and vegetable components. A traditional Reuben sandwich uses corned beef and sauerkraut, typically with Swiss cheese and Russian dressing on rye bread. A Rachel sandwich, on the other hand, swaps the corned beef for sliced turkey and the sauerkraut for creamy coleslaw, usually served with Swiss cheese and Thousand Island dressing on rye bread.

Can I use any type of turkey for my Rachel Sandwich?

Yes, you can! Deli-sliced turkey breast, leftover roasted turkey, or even turkey pastrami all work wonderfully. The key is to have it thinly sliced to ensure even heating and good layering within the sandwich.

Is Russian dressing the same as Thousand Island dressing?

They are similar but not exactly the same. Both are mayonnaise and ketchup-based. Thousand Island typically contains finely chopped ingredients like pickles, onions, and sometimes a hard-boiled egg, giving it a sweeter and chunkier profile. Russian dressing tends to be spicier and often includes horseradish, chili sauce, and Worcestershire sauce. Either can be used in a Rachel sandwich, depending on your preference.

Can I make the Rachel Sandwich ahead of time?

It’s best to assemble and grill Rachel sandwiches just before serving for optimal texture and warmth. However, you can prepare individual components (like dressing the coleslaw or slicing the turkey and cheese) ahead of time and store them separately in the refrigerator. This speeds up assembly when you’re ready to cook.

What’s the best bread for a Rachel Sandwich?

Rye bread is the traditional and preferred choice, offering a distinctive flavor that complements the fillings. Marble rye, dark rye, or Jewish rye with caraway seeds are all excellent options. Choose a sturdy bread that will hold up well to grilling.

Print Recipe
Pin Recipe

No ratings yet
Rate this Recipe

Turkey Reuben Sandwich

This easy Rachel sandwich recipe makes for a quick, flavorful lunch or dinner! This delicious turkey Reuben features layers of Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Thousand Island dressing on toasted rye bread.

Servings:
4 sandwiches

Prep Time:
5 mins

Cook Time:
8 mins

Total Time:
13 mins

Author:
Whitney Bond

Course:
Main Course, Sandwich

Cuisine:
American

Ingredients

• 1 pound roasted or deli turkey, sliced
• 1 cup coleslaw mix
• 1 tablespoon coleslaw dressing
• 8 slices rye bread
• 2 tablespoons butter
• ½ cup Thousand Island dressing, or Russian dressing
• 8 slices Swiss cheese

Instructions

1. Heat a large skillet, or griddle pan, on the stove over medium-high heat. This can be the same pan that you plan to use to cook the sandwiches. Add the turkey and cook for 30-60 seconds per side, or until it’s heated up. Remove the skillet from the heat and set it aside.
2. Toss the coleslaw and coleslaw dressing together in a bowl.
3. Spread one side of each piece of bread with butter and the other side with Thousand Island dressing.
4. Place a piece of cheese on top of the Thousand Island dressing on each piece of bread.
5. Add sliced turkey and coleslaw on top of half of the bread slices, topped with dressing and cheese. Sandwich the other half of the bread slices topped with dressing and cheese over the coleslaw.
6. In the same skillet that you heated up the turkey, wipe it clean, then heat it up on the stove over medium heat.
7. Add the sandwiches to the skillet, or griddle, and grill for 3-4 minutes, flip with a spatula and cook for an additional 3-4 minutes, or until the bread is golden brown and the cheese is melted.

Notes

• I use ¼ pound turkey on each sandwich. If you’d like to make a New York style “sky high” sandwich with a very generous portion of meat, you’ll want to use ½ pound of turkey per sandwich.
• If using thin deli-sliced turkey, you don’t need to heat it up before making the sandwiches.

Nutrition Facts

Calories 609kcal (30%) | Carbohydrates 40g (13%) | Protein 32g (64%) | Fat 35g (54%) | Saturated Fat 13g (65%) | Polyunsaturated Fat 9g | Monounsaturated Fat 9g | Cholesterol 112mg (37%) | Sodium 1850mg (77%) | Potassium 617mg (18%) | Fiber 4g (16%) | Sugar 10g (11%) | Vitamin A 547mg (11%) | Vitamin C 7mg (8%) | Calcium 380mg (38%) | Iron 3mg (17%)

Did you make this recipe?
Tag @WhitneyBond on Instagram and hashtag it #WBRecipes!